Welcome to the best pizzeria in town - Slice of Scarsdale

Best pizza in town
Continuing the tradition of more than a half a century of pizza in the historic village of Scarsdale, Slice of Scarsdale has been a Garth Road staple since early 2016. Having over 40 years of combined experience, owners Mike and Oscar are bringing their old school pizza making skills and culinary artistry to serving Scarsdale the finest food around town.

Mike has been working in Scarsdale for over 20 years and is a world-class pizza-maker and experienced restaurateur. Oscar has 20 years' experience being a head chef in some of NY and CT’s most popular Italian restaurants. Mike and Oscar bring their own blend of hard work and dedication to serving each customer the best pizza and Italian food in the Scarsdale area.


Slice of Scarsdale is so much more than pizza with a wide variety of dishes. We pride ourselves in offering you the very best pizza.


what clients say

Michele M

First time here…driving by and noticed the catchy new name. Walked in and immediately noticed the gentleman who used to work at Amore on Weaver Street… It turns out he’s the new owner.
All I had was a slice of Margherita to go (I think that is what it’s called) and it was unfrigginbelievably deeelish.
I wish the new owners lots of luck. I will definitely be back!


Was awesome. Fun guy at front counter. Usually gives us a show by flipping the pizza dough in the air. Always has a smile and makes awesome pizza. Had a sandwich. Great too!
Recommend the teriyaki slice

Scott Standish-Parkin

I have had almost every food option from here and have yet to be disappointed. The staff are an awesome and friendly group and they will do the best to make any order to your liking. If you have not had them yet, please do your gut and taste buds a flavor and try them out. I suggest getting a wrap or chicken parm pizza on your first visit.

Joan Introzzi

After pricing an octopus appetizer at Alaia, up the block at $20.00, I was thrilled with my freshly fried calamari with lemon for $9.99 at Slice of Scarsdale!

Edward Barrett

The pizza was great… probably 5 stars but I had to take away a star for the Mets decorations. Otherwise a great local pizza spot


Best pizza in westchester county. Try the pizza margarita – delectable sauce w/ crispy delicious crust, just like Italy.

Eugene Kelly

Mike is the best pizza man in all of westchester. Gigantic slices done the right way and absolutely delicious! LOVE THIS PLACE!

Conor Tortorici

Great staff, great dinners, homemade style all the way .. awesome environment, thumbs up on all the different speciality slice options very creative… all around great place to eat lunch quick or dine and get free in house red wine!

Daniel Johnson

Just moved into Scarsdale from out of state. This is an awesome spot. The food is excellent and the owner is a great guy very hospitable. Highly recommend…try the calzones


Get In Touch With Us

drop us a line

© Copyright 2024 Slice of Scarsdale. All Rights Reserved.